Rolf P. Knierim and George W. Coats


Book Details

Series: Forms of the Old Testament Literature
Categories: Numbers
Tags: TechnicalSpecial Study

Book Information

This new commentary on Numbers is not only the latest volume in the respected FOTL series; it is also the first commentary to be written using the exegetical methods of the recently redesigned form-critical approach to the Old Testament literature. Rolf Knierim and George Coats make clear what has traditionally been a difficult portion of Scripture by showing how form criticism sheds light on the text's structure, genre, setting, and intention. Following an extensive introduction to the historical and social background of Numbers, the commentary proper leads readers unit by unit through the text, highlighting the literary development of Numbers and the meaning that it meant to convey to its audience.

Pages: 367 pages
Publisher: Eerdmans
Published: 2005
ISBN-10: 0802822312
ISBN-13: 9780802822314


To review this book, please Login or Register.

4.16666666666667 out of 5 based on 3 user ratings
Jeremy Pierce (parableman) August 7, 2009 2.5 5
George W. Coats and Rolf P. Knierim have done the Forms of the Old Testament Literature volume on Numbers. This is not a commentary but a form-critical study of the book. Many people list this series with commentary lists, so I include it here. I don't find the series very helpful for what most people use commentaries for. This book tends to avoid questions of source criticism to focus on final form structure. They think of the book's primary purpose as a combination of concerns with cultic and military organization, which sets it apart from Leviticus, which reflects none of the military concern. They thus do not see the division between Leviticus and Numbers as arbitrary as many older scholars did. They provide an alternative interpretation of the structure to Olson's view (see above). In some places, they miss big picture structural issues (e.g. the chiastic structure of the rebellion narratives). Reviewers have complained about selective attention to some of the important recent literature on the structure of Numbers. When they do treat source issues, they take a view close to the traditional documentary hypothesis, in the face of much recent work that argues against the traditional assignation of many of these sources. They're often more hesitant to ascribe particular settings to particular passages, however. Coats had written the portion on 10:36 through the end of the book when he stopped work on this book. Knierim wrote the first part, and others were involved in editing Coats's work. [Full Review]
In the last years the book of Numbers has become a very important field of pentateuchal research. Therefore, each new commentary on this book is awaited with much interest. The commentary of Knierim and Coats, two eminent specialists in matters of the Pentateuch, is mainly devoted to a form-critical reading of the book, in compliance with the design of the FOTL project. The diachronic and redaction problems are not denied, but they do not play a major role in the presentation. In the introduction, the authors deal with the overall structure of Numbers. They recognize that the fourth book of the Torah “does not easily reveal a coherent and homogeneous literary work” (6). Nevertheless, the book in its “final” form should be understood as a “saga of the migratory campaign” with a twofold subdivision: “the legend of the organization of the sanctuary campaign” (1:1–10:10) and “the saga of the campaign itself” (10:11–36:13; in a recent work, Knierim’s student, W. Lee argues for the same division: Won W. Lee, Punishment and Forgiveness in Israel’s Migratory Campaign [Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2003]). Knierim and Coats reject Olson’s suggestion that Numbers is organized through the twofold census in Num 1 and 26. This would suggest that the main theme of Numbers is the transition from the old generation to the new (Dennis T. [Full Review]
Die verdienstvolle Reihe hat es sich zur Aufgabe gestellt, eine begrifflich differenzierte Nherbestimmung der literarischen Formen der alttestamentlichen Literatur zu erarbeiten. Hierzu liefert der vorliegende Band (verfasst von R. P. Knierim zu Num 110, G. W. Coats Num 1136, bearbeitet von M. Jacobs und D. Palmer [Claremont]) einen wertvollen Beitrag, dessen Ertrag u.a. in dem (englisch/deutschen) Glossar der Gattungen und Formeln am Ende des Bandes (33767) form uliert ist. Es wird die Verstndigung ber die Bezeichnungen von Redeformen vor antreiben. Demgegenber bleibt die Behandlung der literarhistorischen Probleme des Buches eigentmlich hinter der gegenwrtigen Forschungsdiskussion zurc k. Gerechnet wird mit einem Jahwist (J), vermutet wird ein Elohist (E), der aber dann in der Untersuchung nicht mehr erscheint, sodann vermutet man einen Redaktor JE, dessen Wirken aber fr die Rekonstruktion der Makrostrukturen am Ende auch keine Rolle spielt, und schlielich gibt es das Chamleon Priestly writings, hinter dem sich die Annahme einer wie immer gearteten Priestergrundschrift mit Ergnzungen (Pg, Ps ) verbirgt, sowie die einer Reihe von nicht nher nachweisbaren Corpora priesterlichen Schrifttums, aus denen sich diverse Hinzufgungen des Numeribuches er klren lassen. [Full Review]

Goodreads Reviews

Google Book Preview


Top Commentaries by Book Top Commentaries by Series Forthcoming & Unreleased Commentaries
Pentateuch History Poetry Prophets Minor Prophets
Genesis Exodus Leviticus Numbers Deuteronomy Joshua Judges Ruth 1/2 Samuel 1/2 Kings 1/2 Chronicles Ezra/Nehemiah Esther Job Psalms Proverbs Ecclesiastes Song of Songs Isaiah Jeremiah Lamentations Ezekiel Daniel Hosea Joel Amos Obadiah Jonah Micah Nahum Habakkuk Zephaniah Haggai Zechariah Malachi
OT Primary Source Material OT Canon OT Textual Criticism OT Hermeneutics OT Introductions OT Theology OT Theological Dictionaries OT Archaeology Hebrew Lexicons Hebrew Grammars (Introductory) Hebrew Grammars (Intermediate) Hebrew Grammars (Advanced) OT Backgrounds OT Dictionaries / Encyclopedias OT History and Religion Ancient Near Eastern Histories Israelite Religion OT Extra-Biblical Literature Studies Documentary Hypothesis Deuternomic History Other OT Studies and Issues
Gospels/Acts Pauline Epistles General Epistles
Matthew Mark Luke John Acts Romans 1 Corinthians 2 Corinthians Galatians Ephesians Philippians Colossians 1/2 Thessalonians Pastoral Epistles Philemon Hebrews James 1 Peter 2 Peter/Jude Johannine Epistles Revelation
NT Primary Source Material NT Canon NT Criticism NT Textual Criticism NT Hermeneutics NT Introductions NT Theology NT Theological Dictionaries NT Archaeology Greek Lexical Analysis Greek Lexicons Greek Grammar (Introductory) Greek Grammars (Intermediate) Greek Grammars (Advanced) NT Backgrounds NT Dictionaries / Encyclopedias NT History and Religion NT Near Eastern Histories NT Church History / Apostolic Period NT Extra-Biblical Literature Studies Jesus and the Gospels Synoptic Gospels and Surrounding Issues The Book of Acts in its First Century Setting Pauline Studies Johannine Studies Petrine Studies Lukan Studies Other NT Studies and Issues
Systematics Subjects
Systematic Theology Bible/Bibliology Doctrine of God/Theology Humanity/Anthropology Sin/Harmartiology Jesus Christ/Christology Holy Spirit/Pneumatology Salvation/Soteriology Angels and Demons/Angelology The Church/Ecclesiology End Times/Eschatology Israel/Israelology Rewards/Misthology Other Systematics Biblical Theology Biblical Hermeneutics Biblical Canon Scriptures and Revelation Narrative Themes Prolegomena Trinitarianism Sacraments Providence/Soveriegnty Heaven and Hell Worship Theology Ethics Origins Apologetics Worldviews/Philosophies Biblical Archaeology Environmental Issues Ancient Near Eastern Theology Modern Near Eastern Theology Judaism Messianic Judaism Church History (incl. Post Apostolic) Historical Theology Second Temple Judaism Eternal Security / Assurance Israel and Church - Supersessionism Other Theological Subjects
Christian Life Ministry
Workplace Home Anxiety / Depression etc. Technology Prayer / Intercession Bible Study Cultural Issues Other Life Issues Mission / Evangelism Church Growth Preaching Church Leadership Discipleship Pastoral Care Biblical Counseling Worship Praxis Teaching (Biblical and Rabbinic) Other Ministry
Controller: 00:00:00 ; Template: 00:00:00.0313158