1 Samuel: Studies in Hebrew Narrative & Poetry

David Jobling

1 Samuel: Studies in Hebrew Narrative & Poetry
1 Samuel: Studies in Hebrew Narrative & Poetry

Book Details

Series: Berit Olam
Categories: 1/2 Samuel
Tags: Technical

Book Information

1 Samuel is a national autobiography of the Hebrew people. David Jobling reads 1 Samuel as a story that is complete in itself, although it is part of a much larger narrative. He examines it as a historical document in a double sense: (1) as a document originating from ancient Israel and (2) as a telling of the past. Organizing the text through the three interlocking themes of class, race, and gender, Jobling asks how this historical—and canonical—story relates to a modern world in which these themes continue to be of crucial importance.

While drawing on the resources of biblical "narratology," Jobling deviates from mainstream methodology. He adopts a "critical narratology" informed by such cultural practices as feminism and psychoanalysis. He follows a structuralist tradition which finds meaning more in the text's large-scale mythic patterns than in close reading of particular passages, and seeks methods specific to 1 Samuel rather than ones applicable to biblical narrative in general.

Pages: 330 pages
Publisher: Liturgical Press
Published: 1998
ISBN-10: 0814650473
ISBN-13: 9780814650479


To review this book, please Login or Register.

3.14285714285714 out of 5 based on 7 user ratings
R. Hansen October 31, 2017 2 5
Tackles more theological issues. I did not find this that helpful. Probably just for a specialist in hermeneutical and interpretive issues in Samuel than a commentary
J L Smith August 17, 2011 1 5
This commentary is lucky to even get one star. If I could give no stars I would. It is completely liberal and way out there!
Jeremy Pierce (parableman) August 7, 2009 1 5
David Jobling's Berit Olam (1998) on I Samuel is strong on literary and structural issues, from a very critical perspective that is explicitly and deliberately feminist and postmodernist. If you care about structuralist and Marxist readings of Samuel or interpretations focusing on the Philistines as "the other", you'll enjoy this, but if you're interested in understanding the text this wouldn't be my recommendation. Some conservative reviewers nonetheless find valuable insights in this commentary, but he stands far apart from any attempt to reconstruct authorial intent or to discover what message the text offers to us apart from whatever concerns we might want to derive from it. In some ways this isn't exactly a commentary on the text if that means that it moves through the text in order to discuss it. It reads more like a series of essays that are arranged in a more generally chronological order. [Full Review]
Feminist and deconstructionist essays on the book's structure and message from a modern critical perspective. [Full Review]
Denver Seminary Journal June 16, 2008 4 5
Feminist and deconstructionist essays on the book's structure and message from a modern critical perspective. [Full Review]
This volume is the first English-language study of 1 Samuel as a whole to appear after a five-year lull that followed publication of the concluding volume of Jan Fokkelman's monumental monograph (Narrative Art and Poetry in the Books of Samuel: A Full Interpretation Based on Stylistic and Structural Analyses [4 vols.; Assen: Van Gorcum, 1981-93]). Whether by accident or not, the interpretive modes employed by Fokkelman and Jobling are widely divergent and in many respects antagonistic. While Fokkelman digs deep into the text, Jobling prefers to hover over it, in the sphere of contexts and intertexts. Fokkelman's project rests upon the premise that 1 Samuel can and must be dispassionately studied by objective scientific methods; Jobling is deliberately, if not provocatively, passionate, subjective, and partial. Fokkelman is interested mainly in the author's presuppositions and intentions implicitly operative in the book; Jobling's primary concern is his own interaction with it. Since both Fokkelman and Jobling eschew all kinds of diachronic analysis, differences between them reflect a deep rift within literary-critical, synchronic-minded biblical scholarship. This rift separates the scholars who believe that their task is to figure out what the Hebrew Bible is trying to tell us (text-oriented strategy) from those whose principal objective is to meet certain social, political, cultural, or ideological needs of the late twentieth-century readership (reader-oriented strategy). The reviewed book, repeatedly raising the issues of method and on several occasions (pp. 25-26, 143-44, 288-96) attacking the text-oriented "orthodoxy," represented by Robert Alter, Frank Kermode, Robert Polzin, and Lyle Eslinger, is in fact a large-scale affirmation of the latter approach. [Full Review]
In this contribution to a fascinating commentary series, Jobling examines 1 Samuel according to T. Eagleton's triptych of class, race, and gender. It explores the tension between 1 Samuel as a book in itself and as a part of a larger whole. Jobling's approach to 1 Samuel as Israel's national autobiography is a summation of the course of his own academic career. The 1970s saw him engage structuralism and feminism, while poststructuralism and ideological criticism marked his career in the 1980s. In the 1990s, he turned to new historicism and psychoanalysis. All of these methods come together in an analysis that affords Jobling personal reflection on his own career in a seminary with a high percentage of female students. Jobling denies that ideological criticism can be divorced from the fight for equality for the disempowered. He complains of the "travesty" and "narrowtology" of the new literary "orthodoxy," naming specifically R. Alter, F. Kermode, M. Sternberg, L. Eslinger and especially R. Polzin (e.g., pp. 25, 144, 166-169, 308-309). Jobling replaces these scholars' concern for identifying literary artistry and narratorial omniscience in 1 Samuel with a program of uncovering points at which the text reveals uncertainty over the meaning of the past, and of recovering incompletely suppressed expressions of Israel's premonarchic egalitarian ideals. In chapter 2 Jobling divides 1 Samuel according to book divisions presumably original to the DtrH (following M. Noth and D. J. [Full Review]

Goodreads Reviews

Google Book Preview


Top Commentaries by Book Top Commentaries by Series Forthcoming & Unreleased Commentaries
Pentateuch History Poetry Prophets Minor Prophets
Genesis Exodus Leviticus Numbers Deuteronomy Joshua Judges Ruth 1/2 Samuel 1/2 Kings 1/2 Chronicles Ezra/Nehemiah Esther Job Psalms Proverbs Ecclesiastes Song of Songs Isaiah Jeremiah Lamentations Ezekiel Daniel Hosea Joel Amos Obadiah Jonah Micah Nahum Habakkuk Zephaniah Haggai Zechariah Malachi
OT Primary Source Material OT Canon OT Textual Criticism OT Hermeneutics OT Introductions OT Theology OT Theological Dictionaries OT Archaeology Hebrew Lexicons Hebrew Grammars (Introductory) Hebrew Grammars (Intermediate) Hebrew Grammars (Advanced) OT Backgrounds OT Dictionaries / Encyclopedias OT History and Religion Ancient Near Eastern Histories Israelite Religion OT Extra-Biblical Literature Studies Documentary Hypothesis Deuternomic History Other OT Studies and Issues
Gospels/Acts Pauline Epistles General Epistles
Matthew Mark Luke John Acts Romans 1 Corinthians 2 Corinthians Galatians Ephesians Philippians Colossians 1/2 Thessalonians Pastoral Epistles Philemon Hebrews James 1 Peter 2 Peter/Jude Johannine Epistles Revelation
NT Primary Source Material NT Canon NT Criticism NT Textual Criticism NT Hermeneutics NT Introductions NT Theology NT Theological Dictionaries NT Archaeology Greek Lexical Analysis Greek Lexicons Greek Grammar (Introductory) Greek Grammars (Intermediate) Greek Grammars (Advanced) NT Backgrounds NT Dictionaries / Encyclopedias NT History and Religion NT Near Eastern Histories NT Church History / Apostolic Period NT Extra-Biblical Literature Studies Jesus and the Gospels Synoptic Gospels and Surrounding Issues The Book of Acts in its First Century Setting Pauline Studies Johannine Studies Petrine Studies Lukan Studies Other NT Studies and Issues
Systematics Subjects
Systematic Theology Bible/Bibliology Doctrine of God/Theology Humanity/Anthropology Sin/Harmartiology Jesus Christ/Christology Holy Spirit/Pneumatology Salvation/Soteriology Angels and Demons/Angelology The Church/Ecclesiology End Times/Eschatology Israel/Israelology Rewards/Misthology Other Systematics Biblical Theology Biblical Hermeneutics Biblical Canon Scriptures and Revelation Narrative Themes Prolegomena Trinitarianism Sacraments Providence/Soveriegnty Heaven and Hell Worship Theology Ethics Origins Apologetics Worldviews/Philosophies Biblical Archaeology Environmental Issues Ancient Near Eastern Theology Modern Near Eastern Theology Judaism Messianic Judaism Church History (incl. Post Apostolic) Historical Theology Second Temple Judaism Eternal Security / Assurance Israel and Church - Supersessionism Other Theological Subjects
Christian Life Ministry
Workplace Home Anxiety / Depression etc. Technology Prayer / Intercession Bible Study Cultural Issues Other Life Issues Mission / Evangelism Church Growth Preaching Church Leadership Discipleship Pastoral Care Biblical Counseling Worship Praxis Teaching (Biblical and Rabbinic) Other Ministry
Controller: 00:00:00.0156250 ; Template: 00:00:00.0156250