1 Samuel (2nd ed.)
1 Samuel (2nd ed.)

1 Samuel (2nd ed.)

in Word Biblical Commentary

by Ralph W. Klein

4.33 Rank Score: 5.17 from 6 reviews, 2 featured collections, and 10 user libraries
Pages 366
Publisher Zondervan Academic
Published 2000
ISBN-13 9780849902093


This book appears in the following featured collections.


Add Your Review

G Ware G Ware April 24, 2018
A little light on exposition, and not as thorough as Tsumura, but still very helpful commentary by a top notch scholar on OT narrative texts.
Princeton Seminary Princeton Seminary January 5, 2018
a good semi-technical volume in the same vein as Campbellā€™s.
Ralph Klein's WBC on I Samuel (1983) was the best academic work on I Samuel until Tsumura's NICOT appeared. From what I've seen, I would prefer Tsumura, but for all I know there may be many things Klein is better at. Klein is a skilled textual critic. He is more conservative than McCarter's Anchor Bible but just as knowledgeable about the issues, and he's more willing to defend rather than emend the MT than McCarter is. He still seems a bit too Septuagint-friendly for my tastes. Those with higher views of the LXX than I have will like him, although some might like McCarter even more. I'm not sure I would consider him an evangelical, even though the series advertizes itself as evangelical (in a very loose sense). Klein has a concern for the final form of the text, but he does engage in redaction criticism in a way that's far more speculative than I think is warranted. He is perhaps rivaled only by Tsumura on matters of language, but he gives very little attention to other matters that I would very much want in my preferred commentary on any book, particularly with regard to theology and literary issues. [Full Review]
John Glynn John Glynn September 20, 2008
A commentary concerned with the final form of the text. [Full Review]
Unnatributed-d Unnatributed-d May 26, 2008