Jonah

Phillip Cary

Jonah
Jonah

Book Details

Series: Brazos Theological Commentary
Categories: Jonah

Book Information

Pages: 192 pages
Publisher: Brazos Press
Published: 2008
ISBN-10: 1587431378
ISBN-13: 9781587431371

Reviews

To review this book, please Login or Register.

4.75 out of 5 based on 2 user ratings
Philip Cary’s commentary on the book of Jonah combines profound exegesis with original insights that could serve both the biblical scholar and the layperson. This follows the overall vision of the Brazos commentaries, as R. R. Reno puts it in the series preface: “the commentators in this series have not been chosen because of their historical or philosophical experience.… they are not biblical scholars in the conventional … sense.… Instead, the commentators were chosen because of their knowledge of and expertise in using the Christian doctrinal tradition. They are qualified by virtue of the doctrinal formation of their mental habits” (12). The commentary provides a detailed analysis of each verse, which is indicated both in the text itself and at the top of each page for easier reference. Cary utilizes his own modified combination of the King James Version, Revised Standard Version, New American Standard Version, and the English Standard Version. At the end of the commentary is an epilogue (163–74) with some observations which could be useful for a dialogue between Judaism and Christianity. This is followed by both subject (175–80) and scripture (181–87) indices. [Full Review]
R. Hansen September 13, 2009 4.5 5
After reading Sasson, this book is wonderfully full of life. Like the book of Jonah, it delights and challenges at the same time. It questions and probes and makes you think. While it is easy to read, it is not so easy to grasp. I found myself having to reread many sections. And when done, I wanted to start again to think this all through some more. At times you wish he would explain more – but perhaps the leaving the reader to have to work through the thoughts he started you on is the strength of this commentary. One might say that to completely explain everything would ruin the joke. As if when one got Jonah figured out they could safely leave him behind. (I wrote that while getting near to finishing reading the commentary only to find out his last chapter essentially said his purpose was just that!) While the commentary's strength is getting you to wrestle with text and examine yourself and you own assumptions, I did not find it did so well at placing the text in original setting (he believes that the book of Jonah was originally for returning exiles) and I did disagree with some of his interpretive decisions. Or at least I should say I am not yet convinced by his views. I do not agree with his premise that Jonah is lying in chapter 4 when he gives his reason for not going to Nineveh at first. Cary believes it was simply fear that made him run. And though a strength is letting lots of old testament allusions and symbols enlighten the text, at times he might go to far. I am not yet convinced the gourd represents the David line or the “tent” represents Jerusalem. I hope to do more study and find some commentaries better suited to help me think through those things. But I am thankful for this commentary's contribution to the study of Jonah. One other note. It seems that Cary reads the text as a literary satire while not ignoring or discounting it may be rooted in historical events. I first was introduced to reading Jonah as comic satire by a chapter in the book, “And God Created Laughter, the Bible as Divine Comedy” by Conrad Hyers. I found the chapter online (whether legally or illegally or not I do not know). But one can also read much of that chapter from Google Books. It is very helpful.

Amazon Reviews

Google Book Preview

Sponsors

Top Commentaries by Book Top Commentaries by Series Forthcoming & Unreleased Commentaries
Pentateuch History Poetry Prophets Minor Prophets
Genesis Exodus Leviticus Numbers Deuteronomy Joshua Judges Ruth 1/2 Samuel 1/2 Kings 1/2 Chronicles Ezra/Nehemiah Esther Job Psalms Proverbs Ecclesiastes Song of Songs Isaiah Jeremiah Lamentations Ezekiel Daniel Hosea Joel Amos Obadiah Jonah Micah Nahum Habakkuk Zephaniah Haggai Zechariah Malachi
Backgrounds
OT Primary Source Material OT Canon OT Textual Criticism OT Hermeneutics OT Introductions OT Theology OT Theological Dictionaries OT Archaeology Hebrew Lexicons Hebrew Grammars (Introductory) Hebrew Grammars (Intermediate) Hebrew Grammars (Advanced) OT Backgrounds OT Dictionaries / Encyclopedias OT History and Religion Ancient Near Eastern Histories Israelite Religion OT Extra-Biblical Literature Studies Documentary Hypothesis Deuternomic History Other OT Studies and Issues
Gospels/Acts Pauline Epistles General Epistles
Matthew Mark Luke John Acts Romans 1 Corinthians 2 Corinthians Galatians Ephesians Philippians Colossians 1/2 Thessalonians Pastoral Epistles Philemon Hebrews James 1 Peter 2 Peter/Jude Johannine Epistles Revelation
Backgrounds
NT Primary Source Material NT Canon NT Criticism NT Textual Criticism NT Hermeneutics NT Introductions NT Theology NT Theological Dictionaries NT Archaeology Greek Lexical Analysis Greek Lexicons Greek Grammar (Introductory) Greek Grammars (Intermediate) Greek Grammars (Advanced) NT Backgrounds NT Dictionaries / Encyclopedias NT History and Religion NT Near Eastern Histories NT Church History / Apostolic Period NT Extra-Biblical Literature Studies Jesus and the Gospels Synoptic Gospels and Surrounding Issues The Book of Acts in its First Century Setting Pauline Studies Johannine Studies Petrine Studies Lukan Studies Other NT Studies and Issues
Systematics Subjects
Systematic Theology Bible/Bibliology Doctrine of God/Theology Humanity/Anthropology Sin/Harmartiology Jesus Christ/Christology Holy Spirit/Pneumatology Salvation/Soteriology Angels and Demons/Angelology The Church/Ecclesiology End Times/Eschatology Israel/Israelology Rewards/Misthology Other Systematics Biblical Theology Biblical Hermeneutics Biblical Canon Scriptures and Revelation Narrative Themes Prolegomena Trinitarianism Sacraments Providence/Soveriegnty Heaven and Hell Worship Theology Ethics Origins Apologetics Worldviews/Philosophies Biblical Archaeology Ancient Near Eastern Theology Modern Near Eastern Theology Judaism Messianic Judaism Church History (incl. Post Apostolic) Other Theological Subjects
Christian Life Ministry
Workplace Home Anxiety / Depression etc. Technology Prayer / Intercession Bible Study Cultural Issues Other Life Issues Mission / Evangelism Church Growth Preaching Church Leadership Discipleship Pastoral Care Biblical Counseling Worship Praxis Other Ministry
Controller: 00:00:00.0156250 ; Template: 00:00:00.0781250